Export control of dual-use items and technologies: what to watch out for

Export control of dual-use items and technologies: what to watch out for

Amid the attention on the personal life of Nvidia’s CEO, the question of possible violations of US export control law has been left somewhat in the background. Yet if anything can cause him real trouble, it is precisely potential violations in this area. There are suspicions that Nvidia chips were transferred to companies in Singapore, which then imported them into China, and allegations that Huang knew. All of this remains to be proven.

For years, export control has been neglected in Bulgaria – through ignorance, negligence, or simple unwillingness. The consequences, however, can be very serious. Here is what matters most:

What is export control?

Activities involving certain products and technologies are controlled because of their specific nature. Their export, import, transfer, etc. require prior authorisation, which in practice is the control itself. In general, products and technologies fall into three groups:

Weapons - In legal terms, these are defense-related products. The product must be included either in the common EU list or in the Bulgarian list. Export or import takes place only after authorisation.
Dual-use items and technologies - This is the slipperiest area. These are items and technologies that can be used for both civilian and military purposes. The assessment is strictly specific to each product. Reading Regulation 2021/821 is essential for the details. Export/import of these products is also subject to an authorisation regime, with somewhat broader options than under the weapons regime.
All other products - Anything that is neither a weapon nor a dual-use item. They have free export and import regime

Why does the export control assessment matter?

Hundreds of companies in Bulgaria produce software or hardware, and the results of that production are sent to the EU or abroad. Imagine you develop software related to navigation. Or to object recognition. Or to the operation of aircraft (manned or unmanned), or any other software that is directly or indirectly connected with the products on the list in Regulation 2021/821.

Well, then you probably need to comply with export legislation as well.

The list of dual-use products and items in that regulation is, to put it mildly, enormous. It is 500 pages of technical specifications that no ordinary person can analyse in one day. Artificial intelligence helps, but I warn that, because of the similarities between the criteria in the list, algorithms hallucinate and very often mislead. We have had more than one or two cases in which a company’s manager showed us an AI analysis of their product against the list that looked correct at first glance, but whose nuances made it wrong. I strongly recommend reading the list together with case law, to see how the court reasons.

Because you, AI, or God may believe that your product is not dual-use, but if the court thinks otherwise, you will need to be well prepared to change its mind.

The “catch-all” clause: an unlisted product can also be controlled

A common misconception is that if a product does not appear on the list, no authorisation is needed. The Regulation allows authorisation to be required even for an unlisted product if the exporter knows, or has been informed, that it is or may be intended for specific cases involving weapons and systems listed in the Regulation.
That is why checking the end user and the end use is just as important as classifying the product.

What is the procedure?

1. You are a manager, owner or employee of a company that produces a product (software, hardware or otherwise) which you suspect may be used for military purposes.
2. You check whether it is a weapon under the weapons lists. Important: software can be a weapon if it falls within the weapons list.
     2.1.  If it is a weapon – its export or import is subject to an authorisation regime before the Ministry of Economy, Investment and Industry (MEII). The parties to the transaction, the product’s characteristics, the destination, etc. are specified.
     2.2. If it is not a weapon: check whether it is a dual-use item or technology.
          2.2.1. If it is such an item/technology – export or import is again subject to an authorisation regime before the MEII. This step has its own specifics – the type of destination, for example, may justify a lighter or heavier authorisation regime.
          2.2.2. If it is not such an item – you do not need to comply with the export control regime.
3. After all the checks, you may still not reach a final conclusion on whether your product falls within any of the lists. The MEII has a procedure through which you can ask for its view. The peculiarity of the procedure, however, is that for the MEII to tell you what your product is, it usually wants you to first tell it what you think. This is, of course, a double-edged sword.

Frequently asked questions

1. This is the first time I have heard of such control. Is there a public list of already registered companies so I can compare myself?
Answer: Yes, there is. The public register is here. Currently, more than 120 companies are registered in it.

2. What do you recommend if I wonder whether my product is dual-use?
Answer: Obtain an independent written opinion from a third party who is a specialist in the subject. This will reduce the responsibility of the person making the final decision. In other words, if you are the decision-making body in the company, seek advice. You can also ask the MEII. Incidentally, its refusals to answer are usually not individual administrative acts, so do not waste effort appealing them.
There is settled case law of the Supreme Administrative Court (SAC) on this issue. I would also recommend setting up an internal committee in the company to take a collective decision on whether or not the product falls within any of the lists. The internal decision should be in writing and well reasoned. You must be able to present it to the MEII or the Customs Agency when you open the export regime.
This decision will be the main evidence before the court as to why you classified a given product in a particular way. That is, it is in your personal interest, as the decision-making body, to have a well-reasoned decision.
If you use AI to help – there is nothing wrong with that. At the end, however, validate the result. You need someone who understands the subject to confirm whether what the AI wrote is not simply nonsense.

3. How important is the customs agent?
Answer: Quite. Your customs agent must be experienced – there are specific customs offices that have experience with exporting such products and ones that do not. The former know, for example, that the global authorisation for the USA applies by virtue of EU legislation and that an individual authorisation does not need to be obtained. They also know what to write in the declaration. It is clear that speedy clearance of the regime is measurable in money. So explain to your agent what you are shipping, where, and under which regime you fall.

4. What is the difference between destinations?
Answer: In general, the export of dual-use items and technologies to countries such as the USA, Australia, Canada, etc. (listed in an annex to Regulation 2021/821) is carried out on the basis of the so-called general EU authorisation. This is not an authorisation that is issued specifically; it is, so to speak, issued by virtue of the regulation.
It is important here to state your basis for export to the customs agent. Destinations also matter because the country receiving the items may have its own restrictions on the product. The exporter must indicate EU001 in the customs declaration and notify the competent authority of the first use. The notification is made by a declaration to the MEII 10 days before the export, and a declaration is then submitted again 30 days after the import. See also the implementing regulations to the law.

5. I have not started exporting/importing yet, but I intend to. What should I do?
Answer: Before the import/export procedure, the company must register with the MEII and become part of the list above. If the sole owner of the company is a foreign company, prepare an apostille on the current status certificate. If the parent is registered in a destination such as Delaware, you will face certain obstacles.

6. What liability do I bear as a manager or internal responsible person in the company in respect of export control?
Answer: Besides administrative-penal liability, including penalties of up to EUR 25,000 for a first violation under the law, the manager may also bear criminal liability under the Criminal Code – imprisonment of between 3 and 8 years and a fine of up to EUR 250,000 – in serious cases.
Some of the measures through which you, as a manager, can reduce your liability are to have internal objective procedures that show and prove how you reached the decision that a given product or technology is not dual-use, to have third-party opinions, opinions of an internal committee, an opinion of the MEII, etc. In short, you must be able to prove that the decision you took is well-reasoned and can withstand scrutiny.

7. What should be done if the product as a whole is not on the Regulation’s dual-use list, but part of it is?Answer: There are many such examples. A camera that does not meet the dual-use requirements, but one of its sensors does. There are already many nuances here – can the component be used on its own; can the final product be disassembled, etc. I would definitely recommend a conversation with a specialist here.

Share on XShare via emailShare on LinkedIn

Go to
Offices

Go to Offices